Best Water Heater Repairs in Bargersville, IN (2026)

15 verified businesses · Sorted by rating & reviews

Also in Bargersville

Drain CleaningFaucet Repair & InstallationPlumberSewer Line RepairToilet RepairWater Heater Installation
1

Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis

Google★★★★½4.85.9k reviews
↓ Declining·3 mo: 4.6★ (43)·6 mo: 4.6★ (133)
4040 Industrial Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46254
+1317-886-0567
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
2

Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling

Google★★★★½4.86.4k reviews
Yelp2.5 stars2.550 reviews
↓ Declining·3 mo: 4.3★ (33)·6 mo: 4.3★ (101)
Staff:+chris (2)
1919 E 52nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46205
+1317-912-0222
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling photo 1Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling photo 2Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling photo 3Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling photo 4Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling photo 5Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling photo 6
3

Pristine Plumbing

Google★★★★½4.81.5k reviews
Yelp4 stars3.815 reviews
↓ Declining·3 mo: 4.6★ (27)·6 mo: 4.8★ (80)
5950 W Raymond St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
+1317-680-7064
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
4

L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains

Google★★★★½4.81.0k reviews
Yelp3 stars3.225 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 4.8★ (19)·6 mo: 4.9★ (62)
2400 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46201
+1317-927-7186
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains photo 1L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains photo 2L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains photo 3L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains photo 4L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains photo 5
5

Ciriello Plumbing Co

Google★★★★½4.8628 reviews
↑ Improving·3 mo: 5★ (11)·6 mo: 4.8★ (24)
5715 Churchman Ave Bldg D, Indianapolis, IN 46203
+1317-787-5391
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
6

Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair

Google★★★★½4.9452 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (28)·6 mo: 4.9★ (100)
55 S State Ave Suite 141, Indianapolis, IN 46201
+1317-893-2485
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 1Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 2Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 3Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 4Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 5Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 6Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 7Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 8Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 9Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 10Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 11Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 12Carter's My Plumber - Drain Cleaning Indianapolis & Sewer Line Repair photo 13
7

Plumb Doctor

Google★★★★½4.8366 reviews
Yelp4 stars4.25 reviews
Staff:+chris (2)
5508 Elmwood Ave #304, Indianapolis, IN 46203
+1317-306-9343
Plumber
Call NowView profile →
8

Mr. Plumber by Metzler & Hallam

Google★★★★½4.9525 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (11)·6 mo: 5★ (27)
Staff:+Chuck (2)+keith (2)
711 E 65th St Suite 101, Indianapolis, IN 46220
+1317-956-5116
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
Mr. Plumber by Metzler & Hallam photo 1
9

Weilhammer Plumbing Co. Inc.

Google★★★★½4.8224 reviews
Yelp4.5 stars4.421 reviews
↑ Improving·3 mo: 5★ (4)·6 mo: 5★ (8)
Staff:+Mark (2)+Weilhammer (2)
1819 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
+1317-784-1870
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
Weilhammer Plumbing Co. Inc. photo 1Weilhammer Plumbing Co. Inc. photo 2
10

NuFlow Indy

Google★★★★½4.8138 reviews
↑ Improving·3 mo: 5★ (3)·6 mo: 5★ (4)
1060 N Capitol Ave Suite 3-101, Indianapolis, IN 46204
+1317-245-3733
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
11

Penn Plumbing LLC

Google★★★★★5155 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (10)·6 mo: 5★ (26)
+1317-966-1560
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
12

Tulip Plumbing

Google★★★★★566 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (2)·6 mo: 4.8★ (5)
946 Albany St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
+1317-361-8802
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
13

Moon Family Plumbing

Google★★★★½4.998 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (2)·6 mo: 5★ (4)
3704 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205
+1317-797-1330
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
14

Mister Water Heater

Google★★★★½4.995 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (3)·6 mo: 5★ (9)
2201 E 46th St Ste 161, Indianapolis, IN 46205
+1317-343-4268
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
15

Anderson Family Plumbing LLC

Google★★★★★524 reviews
→ Stable·3 mo: 5★ (4)·6 mo: 5★ (6)
+1317-760-3323
Plumber
Call NowWebsiteView profile →
Anderson Family Plumbing LLC photo 1Anderson Family Plumbing LLC photo 2Anderson Family Plumbing LLC photo 3Anderson Family Plumbing LLC photo 4Anderson Family Plumbing LLC photo 5